“So what exactly makes Taylor Swift so great?” (Harvard’s Version)

The listening studio

Hear one song through three disciplines

Choose a passage or cultural object you can discuss directly.

The Ivy Institute

The listening studio · 1/3

Listen for the craft

Christina Pazzanese’s Harvard Gazette article brings different experts to the same question about Taylor Swift. Start with one feature of a work you care about, such as a shift in narrative perspective.

So what exactly makes Taylor Swift so great? — Harvard Gazette

What a college applicant can learn from reading about Taylor Swift

In August 2023, Harvard Gazette writer Christina Pazzanese put a question about Taylor Swift to people who approached popular music from different fields. The resulting article is interesting even to someone who has never chosen to play a Swift song. An English professor could listen for the way a narrative unfolds. A music educator could notice the choices that make a passage effective. An observer of business or the economy could ask about the activity surrounding a tour. Each could pay careful attention to the same artist and come away with a different question worth pursuing.

Start with a distinction that matters if you are applying to college. A Harvard Gazette article about an artist is journalism. It does not announce an admissions preference or invite applicants to demonstrate that they like the artist. The lesson lies in how people investigate an ordinary cultural experience. A student who reads the source for its method can apply that method to a song, a poster, a neighborhood performance, a game or a book. The subject should be something they already want to look at twice.

What does “great” mean in this question? It could refer to craft, cultural influence, financial performance, influence on other musicians or the experience of a listener. Selling tickets would be relevant to one investigation. It would tell you very little about how a character is introduced in a verse. Technical complexity might matter to another listener but fail to explain why a simple passage makes a crowded room sing. Before debating a conclusion, decide which meaning you intend and what evidence would be necessary to support it.

Read a short portion of Pazzanese's article, set it aside and choose one feature you can observe directly. For a song, it might be a change in who appears to be speaking. For a performance, it might be a point at which the audience responds before the performer resumes. For a poster, it could be the difference between what someone notices from across the street and what is legible up close. Record the observation in one sentence and keep the explanation for the next one. That separation makes room for another interpretation.

Listen once for story and once for sound

On the first pass, describe when the listener learns something new. Does the piece begin in the middle of an exchange? Does the final passage make an early detail mean something different? Does a speaker's point of view seem to shift? Avoid assuming the narrator and performer are the same person. Songwriters can create characters, compress events or let a listener discover information at a chosen moment. A listener can identify the formal choice without making a claim about the artist's private life.

Try an example that does not depend on quoting anyone's lyrics. Imagine a fictional song that opens with an empty chair and returns to the chair after a character has moved away. The object is unchanged in the story, but a listener's interpretation has changed. One listener might hear loss. Another might hear the relief of a difficult departure. A third might find the image overexplained. Each interpretation needs something more than a feeling about the performer. Which order of details or change in sound supports what you heard?

On a second listen, notice time. Does a repeated pattern invite you to predict a particular entrance? When the entrance occurs earlier or later than you expected, what changes? A musician might name the technical device. A beginner can still identify the moment and describe what the ear expected. If you use a musical term you learned from a review, verify that it describes the feature you heard. Careful attention is available before specialist vocabulary. Precision grows when the vocabulary follows the observation.

Then compare what reading and listening revealed. Perhaps a line seems direct in written form but uncertain when the voice pauses. Perhaps the rhythm carries a complicated sequence of events with unusual clarity. You may find that the lyrics need little explanation while the arrangement does more of the emotional work. Keep the contradiction in the note. A college essay can become more interesting when a student shows how a second method revised an initial response. There is no requirement to conclude that the artist is equally remarkable in every dimension.

Build an annotation with evidence small enough to inspect

Give yourself one minute of recorded material or one image. Describe exactly what is present. Then write what you infer and one other reasonable interpretation. If another listener disagrees, ask them to point to the moment that supports their view. Do not vote on who liked the work most. You are testing whether a specific choice can sustain more than one reading. A student working independently can do the same thing by returning a day later and examining what they notice after their first excitement has passed.

Make your notes usable without reproducing the creative work. A time marker, short description of an instrumental change or reference to a particular verse normally suffices for your own study. If writing for an application, your observation is more important than a long quotation. The reader should be able to understand your question even if they have never heard the song. A sentence such as “I kept expecting the same person to explain the argument, then noticed how the second voice changed my sympathy” gives you a direction to develop in your own words.

The listening studio · 2/3

Change the listening channel

A literature student might trace the speaker; a music student might test a rhythmic expectation; a business student might examine distribution. Each interpretation needs different evidence. Avoid attributing a conclusion to an expert who did not make it.

Essays | Undergraduate Admissions

What changes when the discipline changes?

Suppose two students look at the same concert poster. A design student studies the order in which the eye reads the title, location and ticket information. A sociology student wonders whom the imagery invites to feel like an insider. A student interested in economics asks what kinds of tickets were offered and whether local travel affected the experience of attending. Each question could lead to a worthwhile investigation. The poster establishes only part of what each student wants to know. Identify the other evidence before announcing a conclusion.

For the designer, a manageable next step might be to show the poster at different sizes and record which information remains legible. The student could design an alternative hierarchy and ask a willing reader what they notice first. That comparison would say something about these readers and these designs. It would not establish what every ticket buyer thought. A small study becomes more informative when a student describes its limits. The same care applies to an application discussing the project: name what changed and whom you actually asked.

For the student interested in communities, the important question might concern participation. Do people teach one another a custom? Is a repeated gesture easy to join without prior knowledge? What would you need before deciding that a small set of observations represents a broader audience? Public behavior at a performance may suggest a question. It does not reveal the personal history or intentions of every individual present. A respectful account uses public material and avoids identifying a private person without a good reason and appropriate permission.

For the student interested in business, distinguish ticket sales from revenue received by a performer, company profit and economic activity in a city. They represent different quantities. A large reported number should make you ask who estimated it, which period it covers and which spending was included. The Gazette's 2023 article contained reporting and projections made at that time. A projection published while a tour was underway is historical evidence about what observers expected. If you need the eventual figures for another project, look for subsequent reporting using a comparable definition.

Try a fictional calculation to see why definitions matter. Imagine one performance sells 1,000 tickets at a stated average price of 50 dollars. That suggests 50,000 dollars in gross ticket sales under those assumptions. It does not tell you what the venue spent, how revenue was shared or what anyone earned as profit. Money that visitors spend on transport and meals belongs to a different calculation. A student's analysis can improve markedly simply by labeling the quantity and refusing to assign it a meaning the data cannot establish.

Follow a student's interest across two subjects without forcing the link

In an actual Ivy Institute advising conversation, a student was weighing interests that different undergraduate departments placed under different names. Our discussion began with the work the student wanted to do and the questions that connected it. We also considered what the degree rules would permit. A similar problem arises when a student likes both music and another field. “Interdisciplinary” tells a reader very little until the student explains the task. Are you using a second method because it answers a real question, or have you attached a second subject to make the description sound ambitious?

A student interested in language and music might study how the same idea lands differently when a phrase is sung, spoken or printed. They can set up a careful comparison with a short piece of original material. A student interested in mathematics and live performance might examine how a change in seating arrangement alters the share of spectators with a clear view of a stage. Both projects have distinct goals. Neither student needs to claim that liking a pop artist led directly to choosing a lifelong profession. Curiosity may develop one question at a time.

In our advising correspondence about independent study, one student had reached the point of creating a planning document and considering directions. That was a real beginning, distinct from a completed investigation. For the student intrigued by this article, a first plan could consist of choosing one object, identifying a question, naming a source and agreeing on a small output. A two-page interpretation, an annotated sketch or a comparison of two performances could be enough. Do not call it a research finding before you have done the work needed to learn something.

When the results surprise you, describe what would make you change your mind again. If your first reader notices a different emphasis in a poster, try another reader or another viewing distance. If a new recording changes how you hear the same melody, identify which performance choices you can actually compare. The strongest cross-disciplinary work often begins with the realization that one method cannot settle a whole question. Acknowledging the boundary gives the second discipline a real job to do.

Keep the artist and the applicant in the right proportions

An essay can contain several accurate and enthusiastic paragraphs about Taylor Swift and reveal little about the student. Try highlighting every sentence that shows a choice the student made, something they observed or an idea they revised. If those sentences appear only at the end, start a new draft from one of them. The artist can provide the occasion, but the reader needs access to the student's mind. Celebrity biography and an account of record-breaking achievements can crowd out the smaller observation that made the essay worth writing.

A student who disagrees with the article has material too. Perhaps a particular explanation of popularity seems incomplete without examining distribution. Perhaps a listener hears craft in a moment the article does not discuss. State the published point fairly, identify the evidence you examine and explain the scope of your disagreement. An applicant writing from another part of the world might experience the work in translation, a cover performance or alongside local musical traditions. That experience is worth describing if the student knows it directly and resists universal claims about an entire audience.

The listening studio · 3/3

Make your own take audible

Choose a passage or cultural object you can discuss directly. Describe a question, how you investigated it and what changed your mind. Enthusiasm becomes informative when the reader can follow the inquiry.

Turn a listening note into a useful application draft

Choose the prompt before deciding what your note should become. A question about intellectual curiosity might invite the sequence from observation to investigation. A question about community might call for an exchange with another listener. A question about an intended major could require explaining how you want to learn a particular method. The same song or performance can appear in each, but a piece written for one question will not automatically answer another. Write the prompt above the draft and underline the verb that tells you what the reader needs.

In an Ivy Institute writing review, a student had to handle similar community questions across different institutions. We discussed giving the pieces distinct purposes and checking the actual limits. That advice transfers readily to writing about a familiar artist. For one answer, the interesting part could be when a friend offered a rival reading. For another, it might be the design experiment that followed. If neither answers the actual prompt, retain the listening note and choose a different subject. A genuine interest need not appear in every application.

Start a draft by explaining a single change of mind. A fictional student hears an ending as triumphant until a second listener points out how the accompaniment changes beneath it. The interesting action begins when the student goes back to listen and realizes how much of the first interpretation came from expectation. They could examine a second example or decide the first judgment still holds. In either event, the student has thoughts a reader can follow. Do not invent such a conversation for an application. Look for an actual instance when a question persisted after the music ended.

If you are working with an adviser, ask for a reader's account before seeking edits. What did the reader think the essay was about? At what point could they explain the student's observation? Did they need outside knowledge to understand the stakes? We have supported a student choosing between personal statement drafts by considering which felt closer to the student's own voice and giving focused feedback. With a popular culture topic, that boundary matters. An adult who likes different music or has a favorite theory should not take over the student's interpretation.

What to do when family members dismiss a popular culture topic

Ask them to judge the work itself. Can the student explain a feature of the object, describe how they investigated it and identify where a conclusion becomes uncertain? Those tests work equally well for a popular song, a classical performance or a painting in a museum. Familiarity with the topic can be an advantage when it allows a student to notice details another listener overlooks. It can become a disadvantage when the draft assumes everybody loves the artist for the same reason. Make the observation legible to an intelligent reader who starts out indifferent.

The reverse error is to assume that choosing a famous artist automatically makes the essay relatable. A student might spend most of the answer referring to in-jokes or the names of songs without explaining why any one example matters. Try giving the core paragraph to someone who has never heard the track. Ask them to identify the puzzle, the evidence and the student's response. Add a small piece of context if needed. If the essay requires a lengthy introduction to the artist's career before it gets interesting, narrow the example or choose a more direct starting point.

Consider the contribution of other makers. A performance can involve arrangement, production, design, musicians and an audience. When credit matters to your claim, check the relevant source rather than automatically attributing every choice to the most visible person. A student investigating a poster can find out who designed it. A student considering how a concert sounded can distinguish a feature of the composition from a feature of one recording. This is both fairer and intellectually more interesting. A new credit can lead to an entirely different research question.

A listening exercise you can finish this week

Choose one object you can revisit legally and easily. It might be a recording you already use, a publicly available poster, your own performance or a piece a student group has made available. Listen or look once without taking notes. On the next pass, mark a particular moment. Then write three sentences. What did you notice? What do you think it means? What evidence would you need before you could say more? A student who cannot yet answer the third question has found a good place to begin asking for help.

Use a second lens only if it changes the investigation. If your first question concerned narration, listen next for a change in pacing or instrumentation. If the first question concerned who attends a performance, investigate the practical conditions of access before inferring anything about audience preferences. Write down one result that supports your original idea and one that complicates it. You are under no obligation to produce a definitive verdict on an entire body of work. A manageable claim a reader can examine is a stronger achievement than a broad judgment backed only by enthusiasm.

End by returning to the original question about greatness. You may now have a narrower and more personal answer: one particular arrangement changed the way you heard a speaker, one design choice moved a reader's eye or one business figure turned out to describe something quite different from what a headline suggested. The listening worksheet below is a place to keep that answer provisional and record the next source. When an application asks what excites you intellectually, the path from a familiar object to a harder question can be the part worth sharing.

Build a listening annotation

Craft

Object or moment — Start with one feature of a work you care about, such as a shift in narrative perspective.

Lens

Lens I am using — Avoid attributing a conclusion to an expert who did not make it.

Reading

Evidence I would examine — Enthusiasm becomes informative when the reader can follow the inquiry.

The listening studio

Build a listening annotation

Use the prompts to make a note you can take to your next conversation. Your entries stay on this page.

Your working notes

Continue your work

Related reading: Write what someone can carry forward and Draw a clear boundary around a student’s draft.

For more examples or a conversation about your plan: student case studies, advising team, contact The Ivy Institute.

In a whimsical turn of fate (or perhaps a midnight dream come true!), it appears that even America’s oldest academic institution, Harvard, have fallen under the spell of Taylor Swift's harmonious enchantment. Yes, you heard it correctly – the Ivy League colossus has gracefully revealed its newfound affinity for all things Taylor Swift, stepping into the limelight as a proud Swiftie. This revelation is akin to a page straight out of Swift's lyrical playbook, illuminating the venerable halls of academia with a kaleidoscope of emotions, mirroring the narrative threads woven through her melodic tapestries.

Just like the echoes of her songs, Harvard's disclosure resonates with the rhythm of Taylor Swift's pop culture dominion. It magnificently encapsulates the saga of Swift's unparalleled impact on the musical zeitgeist and her echoic sway over the economy. All of this comes to the forefront with an amplified crescendo, buoyed by the recent phenomenon that is her Eras Tour – a melodious voyage that has set hearts ablaze and registers ringing.

As Taylor Swift's lyrics spin tales of love, heartache, and empowerment, Harvard's proclamation adds a dynamic verse to the ongoing ballad of popular culture. The mighty Ivy League institution, known for its storied legacy, has unveiled an unexpected symphony of fandom, harmonizing with the melodies that have resonated in the hearts of millions. And just like Taylor's songs, this proclamation is a celebration of the harmony between artistic brilliance and the cultural tapestry that weaves us all together.

So, as Harvard joins the chorus of Swifties, it casts a spotlight on the enduring rhythm that threads through the tapestry of society – where academia meets the cadence of pop culture, and history dances to the beat of modern melodies. Through this revelation, the prestigious university pens a stanza in the ever-evolving anthem of our time, where the corridors of knowledge and the corridors of harmonies intertwine, each note resonating with the power to uplift spirits, inspire change, and harmonize the melodies of Taylor Swift's legacy with the hallowed halls of academia.

So Harvard, “Can I ask you a question?”

Could Taylor Swift be the distinguished Harvard Commencement Speaker of the year? Could the esteemed university bestow upon her an honorary Harvard degree?

Harvard's recent revelatory piece might just illuminate these burning questions. Yet, it's paramount to acknowledge that securing a place at Harvard's graduation ceremony could prove to be even more exclusive than snagging coveted tickets for the Eras Tour! (Perhaps, we should do a cross analysis on the selectivity of getting into Harvard compared to that of getting Eras Tour tickets. Which do you think is more selective?)

Here’s Harvard’s version of what makes Taylor Swift so great:

Christina Pazzanese‘s article doesn't hold back in highlighting the undeniable influence of Taylor Swift in the current zeitgeist. The release of her album "Midnights" in 2022 serves as the cornerstone of this cultural phenomenon. With a staggering 1.8 million copies sold, it soared to the top of the charts, leaving its closest competitor, Harry Styles, in the dust. Not stopping there, Swift's latest creation, "Speak Now (Taylor's Version)," ascended to the No. 1 spot, marking her 12th time at the pinnacle and surpassing the legendary Barbra Streisand's record.

The heart of the phenomenon, however, lies in Swift's "Eras" world tour, a 131-date marathon tour (with dates continuously being added) that has captured the imagination of fans across the United States and around the world. Harvard's analysis underscores the projected $1.4 billion earnings of the tour, poised to make it the highest-grossing concert tour in history. What's even more remarkable is the collateral economic impact on the host cities, estimated to be a staggering $5 billion. This unprecedented boost has not escaped the attention of even the Federal Reserve, highlighting the far-reaching consequences of Swift's tour on regional economies.

Unpacking Swift's Songwriting Brilliance

Harvard Staff Writer, Pazzanese, introduces us to Stephanie Burt, the renowned poet and Donald P. and Katherine B. Loker Professor of English at Harvard—who unpacks the magic behind Swift's songwriting in a fascinating discourse. The depth of Swift's lyrical finesse shines as Burt meticulously dissects her ability to craft verses that resonate with emotion and narrative. Swift's exceptional command over storytelling, evident in tracks like "Betty" and "Fifteen," is underscored as Burt analyzes her capability to seamlessly blend verses to create a vivid and coherent story.

Burt goes on to emphasize the depth of Swift's artistry, highlighting her unique capacity to create verbal hooks that leave an indelible mark on listeners. While Swift's harmonic progressions may appear conventional, her mastery of melody and lyricism remains unparalleled. This fusion, as Burt elucidates, resonates deeply with fans and contributes to the remarkable staying power of her songs.

Swift's Intimate Connection with Fans

Next, Pazzanese interviews Harvard’s Alexandra Gold, a clinical fellow in psychology at MGH and Harvard Medical School, who offers a psychological perspective on Swift's unique bond with her fan base. Gold's analysis delves into the phenomenon of fan devotion, emphasizing the profound emotional connection Swift cultivates with her audience. Gold posits that Swift's relatable lyrics, which encapsulate universal human experiences, serve as a bridge connecting fans' personal identities with her music.

Gold underscores the generational impact of Swift's music, drawing attention to its significance for both Millennials and Gen Z. For Millennials, Swift's journey of growth and transformation parallels their own, fostering a sense of shared experiences. On the other hand, Gen Z discovered Swift through the platform of TikTok during the pandemic, leading to an emergence of a new generation of Swifties who connect with her music on a personal level.

Economic Tidal Waves: Swift's Concerts Bringing Life & Energy Back to Local Economies

But, let’s talk about that $5 billion Taylor Swift added to the US economy. And, to do so, Pazzanese interviews Matthew Andrews, Edward S. Mason Senior Lecturer in International Development at Harvard Kennedy School, who delves into the economic tidal wave set in motion by Swift's concerts. Andrews situates Swift's "Eras" tour within the context of mega events, drawing parallels with the Super Bowl's economic impact. The forecasted $5 billion economic surge generated by Swift's tour across host cities sparks a conversation about the concert's role as a catalyst for local economic growth.

Andrews' analysis doesn't merely focus on the financial aspect. It also raises poignant questions about the impact of such large-scale events on public infrastructure, climate concerns, and the community at large. The juxtaposition of economic prosperity and potential challenges forms a comprehensive understanding of the multifaceted influence of Swift's tour.

Taylor Swift: A Trailblazer in Business and Artistry

From being a lyrical mastermind to bejeweling the economy, not even Kanye (sorry, had to do it) could deny that Taylor Swift is a remarkable businessperson. To shed light on the business side of Taylor Swift success, Pazzanese speaks with Ralph Jaccodine, assistant professor of music business/management at Berklee College of Music, who adds a business-oriented dimension to the analysis, dissecting the factors that have propelled Swift to the pinnacle of the music industry. Jaccodine attributes Swift's unrivaled success to her mastery of songwriting, the bedrock on which her empire is built. He highlights that Swift's songs, marked by their enduring quality and profound impact, are a testimony to her enduring artistry.

In addition to her musical prowess, Jaccodine underscores Swift's ability to evolve and adapt within the industry. He lauds her fearless experimentation, noting how she engages her audience with every shift in her creative journey. Swift's business acumen, as demonstrated through her advocacy for artist compensation and control of her back catalog, adds another layer to her persona, positioning her as a role model for aspiring musicians.

Christina Pazzanese's article reveals a facet of Harvard that is perhaps less commonly seen – an institution captivated by the force that is Taylor Swift. This charismatic exploration into Swift's impact on pop culture and the economy seamlessly weaves together insights from experts, academicians, and psychologists. The synthesis of these perspectives forms a comprehensive tapestry that portrays Swift as more than just a pop sensation – she's a cultural trailblazer, a lyrical virtuoso, and an economic powerhouse that even Harvard couldn't resist serenading.

So Harvard, if you had a Blank Space on your campus, would you make our Wildest Dreams come true and offer Taylor Swift an acceptance? I see a Crimson (Taylor’s Version) collaboration in the future!

Previous
Previous

For the Ivy League, you apply to be both a student… and a teacher!

Next
Next

How much time do colleges spend reviewing a student’s application?