What is the best way to get accepted to Harvard? (…by accident!)

The accidental field notebook

Track what you did before you called it preparation

Tell someone unfamiliar with the work what you learned and what still frustrates you.

The Ivy Institute

The accidental field notebook · 1/3

Record the ordinary day

The original Harvard column asks why a student might experience an offer as a surprise. The useful part of that story is the work done before anyone called it an application strategy.

What admissions criteria do you use? | Harvard

What someone usually means when they say Harvard happened by accident

Picture a student who spent a year learning to repair bicycles because neighbors kept bringing over the same kind of brake problem. When a friend asks what they did to prepare for selective college admissions, the student may say “nothing special.” That answer doesn't mean they spent the year idle. They worked on something they would have chosen without an admissions audience. They may later be surprised by the decision a college makes. Surprise tells us how the student felt when they opened the letter. It tells us very little about why a committee reached its decision.

The phrase “by accident” is useful if it draws your attention to learning that was never designed as an application strategy. It becomes misleading if anyone interprets it as a formula for getting into Harvard. Ignoring instructions, deliberately underpreparing or choosing the opposite of every popular activity has no special admissions virtue. Harvard describes considering academic preparation and a range of personal and extracurricular contributions. Each applicant controls what they study, how they participate and whether the application accurately represents them. The institution controls admission.

The original question asks for the best way to get accepted. No family or outside adviser can reliably identify that path for an individual. A more workable version is to ask which decisions would make a student better prepared for demanding college work, allow them to contribute to people around them and leave them with options they value. Those goals hold up whether the student applies to Harvard, chooses a different college or ultimately takes another route. They can be pursued deliberately without making a single uncertain outcome the organizing principle of high school.

Recover the work you did before anyone gave it a label

Begin with a week, not a résumé. On Monday, where were you after classes? What occupied Tuesday evening? What did someone ask you to help with on Saturday? Write ordinary answers, including homework, travel, work, care at home, practice and rest. Then circle one moment when you made a choice. A student helping a customer might have had to explain a confusing instruction. Someone playing music might have tried a different way to cue an entrance. These observations can lead to a question even when there is no club or award to list.

Now ask what you returned to when nobody was counting the hours. It could be an activity that belongs on an application. It could also be ordinary pleasure that deserves to remain private. The purpose of the inventory is to remember what actually fills your life and notice which experiences taught you to make decisions. There is no obligation to turn your favorite book, family relationship or weekend hobby into a project. Some interests become more meaningful when they have time to develop before anyone asks them to serve another purpose.

The difference between repetition and development is worth investigating. Suppose you repaired the same kind of bicycle twice. The first time you followed a checklist. The second time you noticed that the checklist assumed the cable had been installed correctly. You learned to check that assumption before beginning. If you worked on a third bicycle, what would you inspect first? The answer shows a change in your understanding. The scale of the activity is modest, but a stranger can follow the learning. That is useful evidence whether or not you ever describe it to a college.

In an Ivy Institute review of seven students' working activity inventories, we found 84 entries on the later lists. Thirty had no clear earlier match, but only seven could be verified as experiences that had already begun when the first lists were made. Some of the apparent additions represented genuinely new experiences or uncertain timing. The lesson for a student preparing for Harvard is about memory and accuracy. A longer inventory can help discover work you overlooked. It cannot automatically be treated as proof that you had been doing every activity all along.

Begin a field notebook that takes five minutes

Try one page for an experience you are still exploring. Give it a date. Write what you thought would happen, what actually happened and one question the difference raised. If you tried a solution, say what changed afterward. If you only formed a question, leave it there. You might later use the page when discussing course choices with a teacher or deciding whether to try a project over summer. Its immediate value is that you can return to your own observation before someone else's description replaces it in your memory.

Choose a detail you could explain to another person. If you write “the project was successful,” a later reader still has to guess what you achieved. If you write that two classmates both misunderstood the same step and you divided it into two instructions, the next experiment is clear. Ask another reader to try the revision. If it is still confusing, the project has not failed as a learning experience. You now know that the explanation may depend on background information you assumed everyone shared.

Students sometimes fear that a notebook with small mistakes will make them look less accomplished. Here it is a private working tool. Keeping the unsuccessful attempt can help you see how your method developed, which later makes a truthful account easier to write. An application may have room for only one decision and its consequence. Choosing that decision feels easier when the alternatives are recorded. It should be the student who decides whether the story is worth sharing and how much space it deserves.

The accidental field notebook · 2/3

Look for a repeat

A student who fixes bikes for neighbors may start keeping a repair log after the same problem appears three times. The log documents a developing question. It does not need to become an admissions campaign.

Applying Sideways | MIT Admissions

Choose academic challenge for a reason you can explain

Harvard's public admissions guidance emphasizes the academic work a student has undertaken as part of a broader review. Start with what your high school offers, how courses build on each other and where your interests require additional preparation. A student who wants to investigate patterns in a community survey may have a sound reason to study statistics. Someone who wants to understand a difficult text in the original language may choose another year of language. A demanding course is most useful when the student has a sensible route into it and time to do the work.

In an Ivy Institute advising exchange about a student's academic record, the correspondence discussed how the level of coursework and grades changed together over time. The progression was more informative than a bare count of advanced courses. An applicant can investigate the same issue term by term. What was unfamiliar at the beginning? Where did the work become more demanding? What support did the student use and what did they learn to do independently? A counselor can supply factual school context. The student can decide whether their own experience adds something meaningful to the application.

If your school lacks a particular advanced class, find out how the school profile explains course availability before looking for an expensive substitute. Could you pursue a demanding question within an existing class? Is an outside course feasible and appropriately sequenced? Will the school or receiving college issue the credit you expect? A responsible plan takes account of the bus ride, the work shift and the other courses, as well as the material you want to learn. Taking on a course with no realistic way to attend can make an otherwise interesting idea unworkable.

Consider two students who both love local history. One might ask a librarian to show them how to compare contemporary records from different sources and then try the technique on a manageable question. The other might enroll in a formal course that supplies the background they need to interpret those records. Each route can develop academic judgment. Which is feasible depends on access, cost, existing knowledge and how the student learns. It is unnecessary to invent a research affiliation to describe either choice. Being accurate about who taught you a method is part of doing serious work.

How to pursue curiosity without promising an outcome

Before asking a professor or organization for an opportunity, read something the person has actually produced. In an Ivy Institute meeting, the discussion of a possible research connection included learning about the person's work before seeking a role. The suggestion was a next step. It did not establish that the student had become a researcher or received an invitation. A student can begin by explaining one method they do not understand or asking a focused question that arises from a public piece of work. A substantive question remains worthwhile even if no reply comes back.

Be precise about what a new opportunity offers. Will you observe, practice a method, help maintain a record or develop a question of your own? A student watching an expert may learn a great deal without claiming to have directed a project. A teenager working independently might exercise considerable responsibility with basic tools. These experiences are different and can both be valuable. Ask what evidence would show progress by the end of a few weeks. It could be an explanation you can now give, a comparison you can defend or a small object that someone else can use.

Suppose you want to learn why two accounts of the same local event disagree. Start by identifying when and for whom each account was written. Compare the details both include and the facts only one reports. Decide which further source would help resolve a discrepancy. You may find that an answer is unavailable. A brief note explaining why the question remains open can demonstrate intellectual care. It is preferable to announcing that you settled a historical controversy simply because you completed a summer project.

Ask yourself whether the project would still deserve a few hours if Harvard disappeared from your list tomorrow. If yes, keep going and adjust its scope to your life. If the answer is no, try to identify why you first agreed to it. Perhaps you want a skill the project promised to teach but the current arrangement involves mostly administrative work. A conversation with the organizer might change that. Perhaps you simply prefer another pursuit. Finishing a clear obligation and handing it over responsibly can be a thoughtful choice.

Read successful applications without treating them as recipes

A published essay can show what a writer put on a page. It does not reveal how their teachers described them, what else the file contained or why a reader voted a particular way. Even a clearly documented offer cannot establish that a story, activity or wording caused it. A collection selected for favorable outcomes also lacks the comparable unsuccessful applicants you would need to test a claim about admission chances. Read for techniques you can understand, such as how a writer made a confusing decision clear. Leave the biographical details with their owner.

In one of our research reviews, accounts of admitted students showed family responsibilities or paid employment much more often in longer anonymous accounts than in university or scholarship profiles. That difference concerns what was published. It cannot establish how often the students in either group actually worked or cared for someone. The practical question for a Harvard applicant is what a polished profile may have left out. A headline about a prize rarely gives you a full week of someone's life. It makes little sense to redesign yours around the visible portion of theirs.

When reading a sample essay, cover the college and organization names. Can you describe a moment when the writer changed their mind, helped someone or learned why their first approach was inadequate? If yes, learn from how the information was arranged. If you can remember only the name of a laboratory, trophy or university, the sample may have little to teach about writing. A student who likes the subject should investigate it independently. Borrowing the language or details would obscure the applicant the essay is supposed to introduce.

Harvard on extracurricular activities · Our paired activity-inventory review · Our review of published student profiles

The accidental field notebook · 3/3

Test your explanation

Tell someone unfamiliar with the work what you learned and what still frustrates you. Harvard describes several considerations in admission. A single applicant’s surprise cannot explain how a committee reached a decision.

Write so a stranger can follow your actual decisions

Start a personal statement draft by telling someone about an event in the order you remember it. Skip the opening you think an admissions officer expects. If the interesting part happened when a plan stopped working, begin there in the draft. Explain what you tried, what made you choose it and what you saw afterward. Later you can move the starting point or remove unnecessary setup. A draft is a place to discover what the story is about. Requiring a polished moral in the first sentence can make an applicant abandon their best material.

In a real Ivy Institute correspondence review, a student had two possible personal statement drafts. Our team supported the one that felt closer to the student's own voice and recommended targeted refinements. The student's preference about what to share mattered. There was no need to manufacture a more dramatic identity. If you are deciding between a quiet story and an impressive-sounding one, ask what each lets a reader understand that the rest of the application does not. Choose the one you can explain in your own words and revise without losing what actually happened.

Check that reflection follows from the event. A teenager who fixed a mechanical fault might have learned to inspect an assumption rather than to persevere in every situation forever. A person who misread a classmate might have learned to ask a clearer question. Small, specific lessons are easier to support. Show the draft to a trusted reader and ask what idea they understood from the event. If they infer a lesson you did not intend, identify the phrase that led them there and decide whether it needs revision. The final choice and language should remain yours.

Avoid repeating the same achievement in every space simply because it feels strongest. An activity description may already tell the reader your role and the time you spent. A shorter response could reveal what happened when you had to give someone else room to disagree. A personal essay might explore a part of your life with no obvious link to the activity. Give each piece a purpose. Overlap makes sense when it adds new information. Otherwise a reader may learn surprisingly little from an application that is perfectly consistent from start to finish.

Take the application seriously even if your interests developed by accident

Check Harvard's currently published application requirements for the year and route you intend. You will need a plan for material you produce, material the school supplies and any other required components. Separate the date a request must be made from the university's deadline. If your counselor cannot prepare an official document until a grading period ends, record that dependency. If you are preparing applications to other institutions, check which questions and requirements actually differ. A good plan can reduce the time spent on logistics and leave more room for school and the interests you care about.

In one of our application reviews, a submission-format preview showed that an additional-information response ran across multiple pages. Our feedback was to check how the paragraph breaks appeared before the student submitted it. That is a mundane detail, and precisely the kind of thing an applicant can control. Read the final version where the institution will see it. Check whether a line disappeared, an abbreviation needs explanation or one draft was pasted into the wrong box. Keep the confirmation after submitting. A completed essay and a received application are separate milestones.

Give Harvard a place on a list that would still work after a disappointing decision. Identify colleges where you would be glad to study and whose costs, program access and ordinary life make sense for your family. In one documented list review, a student had received an offer from an institution they preferred to another school they were considering. We discussed whether continuing the other application served the student’s interests. The aim is to create real choices. An application plan built around only one possible happy outcome is fragile, however thoughtfully the applicant approaches that one college.

Decide what you would keep doing the morning after decisions

Imagine three letters. One gives you the offer you hoped for. One leaves you waiting. One says no. Which class, person or project would still deserve your attention the following morning? Write the answer before decisions arrive. It might be a younger student who depends on you, a piece of music you have yet to play well or a research question for which you just found a better source. Those commitments can form a useful college application because they have substance. Their value does not originate in the letter.

Use the field notebook below for something you did voluntarily, a pattern you noticed and the next question you want to pursue. Revisit it after you have done a little more work. If the next question changed, write the new one instead of forcing the first plan to fit. A student surprised by where that habit eventually leads may call it an accident. The curiosity, choices and work along the way are specific enough to remember and worth taking seriously.

Write a curiosity note

Notice

Something I did voluntarily — The useful part of that story is the work done before anyone called it an application strategy.

Repeat

A pattern I noticed — It does not need to become an admissions campaign.

Explore

A question I would keep pursuing — A single applicant’s surprise cannot explain how a committee reached a decision.

The accidental field notebook

Write a curiosity note

Use the prompts to make a note you can take to your next conversation. Your entries stay on this page.

Your working notes

Every year, Ivy Day unfurls a captivating paradox. As the eight Ivy League institutions unveil their admissions verdicts, two distinct cohorts of students emerge: those who are pleasantly surprised by their acceptance, having invested minimal effort, and those who stand in disbelief, having exhausted every avenue to secure a coveted spot. There is a reason this pattern exists each year, and the answer to this dichotomy lies within the lessons that can be learned from each group of surprised students regarding “what to do” and “what not to do” when trying to get accepted to Harvard or other top colleges. This paradoxical scenario compels us to ponder: Could the best path to Harvard (or any Ivy League institution) actually be an accidental one?

Beneath this paradox lies a profound truth, often overlooked by many students. The pattern is far from enigmatic; it mirrors the core values cherished by Harvard and other elite establishments. The relentless pursuit of admission often steers students onto a path where their authentic selves become obscured. Everything revolves around what they can do to dazzle the admissions officers. Paradoxically, it's this very mindset that can lead to rejection.

Harvard and its Ivy League peers are not on the hunt for students who are mere résumé artisans. Instead, they seek individuals who are authentic, passionate, and propelled by genuine interests and sources of joy. These students immerse themselves in activities aligned with their core values, and their achievements organically align with their passions. It's not about striving to fit a predetermined mold; it's about staying true to one's essence.

For the students "surprised" by their acceptance despite minimal exertion, their exceptionalism emanates from their core. They shine not because they intended to make an impression, but because they remained authentic. Their genuineness captured the Ivy League's attention, and they reaped the rewards of being true to themselves.

In a world saturated with inquiries like, "What must I do to enhance my chances at XYZ college?" we frequently overlook the most pivotal question: "What should I do to elevate my personal contentment, realize my true aspirations, and evolve into the finest version of myself?" The latter question holds the key to success, not solely within the admissions landscape but in life's broader canvas.


Honestly, a student is far more likely to get accepted to Harvard by doing almost entirely the opposite of everything they believe (and others believe) Harvard is looking for, as then—and only then—may a student be on a path that Harvard has never seen before. And that will surely catch their attention! Then, if a student pursues that path with relentless curiosity and determination, they will likely keep Harvard’s (or any college’s) attention all the way to an acceptance!


The lesson is clear: Refrain from losing yourself in the relentless pursuit of Ivy League admission. Authenticity and an unfeigned passion for your pursuits will set you apart more emphatically than any meticulously constructed application ever could. It appears that the finest avenue to Harvard is indeed the path of authenticity, driven by pursuits that genuinely resonate. Ultimately, it's not about impressing the admissions committee; it's about impressing yourself with the life you lead and the person you become.

So, we would like to leave all students with this: Don’t chase after and define yourself by any particular college; rather, define yourself solely by who you are, and the colleges will chase after you!

Previous
Previous

How pursuing an application “spike” can, actually, lead to a denial in college admissions.

Next
Next

Admissions Review: What are my chances at “Upenn (ED), Princeton, USC, UNC, Cornell, UMich, NYU, Notre Dame, Duke, Johns Hopkins. Really any t20 in one of my possible chosen majors?” (Reddit Post)