Building a Balanced College List: Finding Your Reach, Match, and Safety Schools (Guest Post)
Written by Margie, Guest Contributor & Social Media Expert
Creating a college list can feel like a monumental task.
The word "college list" alone can conjure images of pages filled with schools, deadlines, rankings, and stats.
But really, it's about discovering which colleges align best with your goals, interests, and aspirations.
This process isn't just about numbers or reputation; it's about finding a place where you'll thrive both academically and personally.
Here's a step-by-step breakdown to help you create a balanced list, complete with real examples and stories from students who’ve successfully navigated this journey.
Why a Balanced College List Matters
Imagine you’re setting off on a road trip.
Would you pick a single route without a backup?
Of course not—you’d choose several options to ensure that, no matter what, you reach your destination.
A balanced college list works the same way.
By including a range of schools in three categories—reach, match, and safety—you’re setting yourself up for a successful application season.
Reach schools might be a bit of a stretch but are worth a shot; match schools align well with your stats and fit your academic profile, while safety schools are those where your admission chances are particularly strong.
Step 1: Understanding the Reach, Match, and Safety Categories
Reach Schools
Reach schools are those where your academic profile might be slightly below the average admitted student’s stats.
For instance, if the college’s average SAT score is 1450 and your score is 1380, it would likely be a reach school.
These colleges are competitive and typically admit a lower percentage of applicants.
Consider the story of Amy, a high school senior who had always dreamed of attending an Ivy League school.
Although her GPA was strong, her test scores were just shy of their averages.
She applied to a few of these “reach” colleges, acknowledging that while it was a stretch, it was still possible.
Match Schools
Match schools are where your academic achievements align well with the school’s averages.
Your GPA, test scores, and extracurriculars fall within the typical range of admitted students.
These schools offer a reasonable chance of acceptance and are likely a great fit for both your academic and social preferences.
Jake, a junior, decided to add some match schools to his college list after visiting campuses where he felt at home.
He looked for schools with academic programs that matched his interests but were also known for having a balanced student life.
For him, these schools felt like an achievable and comfortable next step.
Safety Schools
Safety schools are where your academic profile exceeds the averages for admitted students.
These are your backup options, but that doesn’t mean they’re any less important!
Safety schools should still offer programs, communities, and experiences that excite you.
After all, if you end up attending a safety school, you want to feel like it’s a great choice rather than a fallback.
Consider Sara, who applied to a mix of private and public universities.
One of her safety schools was her state university, which had a solid program in her intended major.
In the end, she chose to attend her safety school because of a generous scholarship package that made it a fantastic financial decision.
Step 2: Choosing Criteria That Matter Most to You
Creating a college list that reflects what’s truly important to you can lead to a rewarding college experience.
Here are some factors to consider:
Size of School: Think about whether you want a small, intimate campus where you know everyone or a large university with endless opportunities.
Location: Urban, suburban, or rural? Each location has its unique advantages.
Cost: Be realistic about tuition costs and financial aid.
Academic Programs: If you’re passionate about environmental science, prioritize schools known for that program.
Campus Culture: Some students want a school with a strong athletic culture; others prioritize research opportunities.
These preferences help shape a list that reflects your goals and needs.
Step 3: How to Research Schools Effectively
Research is essential to create a realistic and balanced list.
Here’s how to dive deep without feeling overwhelmed:
College Websites: Start with each school’s official website, where you’ll find detailed information about programs, campus life, and admissions criteria.
Virtual Tours: Many schools offer virtual tours, allowing you to “visit” the campus from your home.
College Fairs and Info Sessions: Attend local or virtual college fairs where you can speak directly with admissions reps.
Alumni and Student Reviews: Hearing firsthand accounts from current students and alumni can offer invaluable insights into a college’s culture and atmosphere.
Step 4: Testing Your List for Balance
Once you’ve gathered a list of potential schools, it’s time to test for balance.
To ensure a diverse range of options, a good rule of thumb is 2-3 reach schools, 3-4 match schools, and at least 2 safety schools.
This approach gives you a variety of choices while also increasing your chances of acceptance.
Imagine having a mix like this:
Reach: Stanford, Columbia
Match: Boston University, University of Michigan
Safety: University of Arizona, State College
Each school category has purpose and potential, making the final decision exciting, not daunting.
Real-Life Example: A Balanced College List in Action
Meet Daniel, a student with a clear passion for computer science.
His dream was to attend a top-ranked program, but he also valued a collaborative and research-focused environment.
Using the steps above, he created his balanced list:
Reach: Carnegie Mellon University
Match: University of Illinois Urbana-Champaign, Georgia Tech
Safety: State University, City University
In the end, Daniel’s careful planning paid off—he was accepted to a match school with a program that checked all his boxes.
His story shows how a well-researched college list can lead to exciting and achievable outcomes.
Tips to Make Your College List Stronger
Stay Open-Minded: Don’t dismiss schools based solely on rankings.
Plan Visits (If Possible): Even a brief visit can tell you a lot about whether a campus feels right.
Look Beyond Academics: Think about clubs, housing, food options, and other aspects that make a college feel like home.
Revisit Your Goals Often: As you grow, your interests may change. Update your list to reflect any shifts in your preferences.
Apply for Scholarships: Safety and match schools often offer merit scholarships, so apply to keep your options open.
Moving Forward with Confidence
Crafting a college list might seem overwhelming, but with the right mindset, it can become a rewarding journey.
A thoughtful approach ensures you have schools in each category, making application season much smoother.
Remember, the college you attend is only one part of your path—it’s what you make of the experience that truly matters.
A balanced college list isn’t about limiting options; it’s about maximizing the chances of finding a school that feels like home, a place where you can grow, learn, and succeed.
Discover the difference of The Ivy Institute—where if you can dream it, we can build it! At The Ivy Institute, we don’t just help students get accepted into top Ivy League and Ivy Plus colleges — we have the resources to develop students into the candidates top colleges and admissions officers seek, and transform your CommonApp college application and essays. Join us for a 30-minute information session on applying for college with an Ivy League expert and see how we can make your college dreams a reality. Schedule your consultation today!
