Choosing Between the SAT and ACT: Which Test Is Right for You
Written by Anthony, The Science Academy
Understanding the SAT and ACT Tests
When it comes to preparing for college admissions, understanding the SAT and ACT is essential. These standardized tests play a significant role in shaping future college paths for millions of students. However, deciding which test to take—or even if you should take both—depends on various factors. Let’s dive into the differences between these two exams and help you determine which one might be the best fit for your strengths and aspirations.
The Basics: Key Differences Between SAT and ACT
Both the SAT and ACT are designed to assess a student's academic readiness for college. However, they have unique structures, focuses, and scoring methods, which can impact how well you might perform on each.
The SAT is known for its emphasis on reasoning and problem-solving skills. It includes sections on Math, Evidence-Based Reading, and Writing and Language. The Math section is divided into two parts—one allowing a calculator and the other not—making it ideal for students comfortable with mental math. The scoring for SAT ranges from 400 to 1600.
The ACT, on the other hand, is a faster-paced test that covers English, Math, Reading, and Science Reasoning, as well as an optional Writing section. One unique feature of the ACT is its Science section, which evaluates a student’s ability to interpret, analyze, and problem-solve scientific information. Scored from 1 to 36, the ACT can be a better choice for students who excel in scientific or technical areas.
Both exams are widely accepted by colleges and universities, so your choice should be based on which test best showcases your strengths.
Choosing Your Test: Which One Fits You?
When deciding between the SAT and ACT, consider your personal strengths and test-taking preferences. If you're someone who works well under time constraints and enjoys science, the ACT may be the better option. Alternatively, if you excel at problem-solving and have strong math skills, you may find the SAT more suited to your abilities.
Let me share an example: When I was helping my younger cousin prepare for college admissions, we decided to start with the SAT. She was strong in math but found the time pressure of the ACT challenging. After practicing with both tests, it became clear that the SAT was her best fit.
It’s often worth taking a practice test for both exams to see which one feels more natural for you. You can access free resources and sample questions for the SAT and ACT online, which is a good starting point.
SAT and ACT: Differences in Content and Skills Assessed
When it comes to content, the ACT’s inclusion of a Science section is a notable difference. This section doesn’t require you to memorize scientific facts but instead assesses your ability to interpret and analyze data. If you enjoy reading charts, graphs, and understanding experimental setups, the ACT Science section could play to your strengths.
For example, in my high school days, I found that I enjoyed the ACT because of the variety it offered. Switching between English, Math, and Science felt dynamic and kept me engaged throughout. My friend, however, found the test too quick-paced and preferred the SAT’s deeper focus on critical reading and analytical writing.
The SAT’s Math section places a strong emphasis on algebra and data analysis, with some advanced math questions. The ACT’s Math section, however, includes additional questions on trigonometry, making it a more comprehensive math assessment. If you’re comfortable with these topics, this can be an area where you shine on the ACT.
Timing and Pace: SAT vs. ACT
The SAT and ACT vary greatly in terms of time pressure. The ACT is notorious for its rapid pace, with less time allotted per question compared to the SAT. For example, the ACT’s Reading section has 40 questions in just 35 minutes, while the SAT allows 65 minutes for 52 Reading questions. This means the SAT offers more time for you to process information, which can be beneficial if you prefer taking a thoughtful approach.
Another aspect to consider is the test length. The ACT, including its optional Writing section, is slightly shorter than the SAT. If endurance is a concern, this could be a deciding factor. My cousin, for example, preferred the SAT’s pace, as it gave her more time to think through each question without feeling rushed.
Preparation Tips: How to Excel on Each Test
Success in either the SAT or ACT depends on preparation, and each test requires a different strategy. Here are some effective tips for both exams:
Preparing for the SAT
For the SAT, focus on building strong critical reading skills and improving your essay organization. Practice analyzing texts to answer questions more efficiently. Also, spend time working on mental math to navigate the no-calculator section with confidence.
To improve in the Math section, concentrate on algebra and problem-solving strategies, as these skills are heavily featured on the SAT. Using a study plan or enrolling in a test prep course can help you target these areas.
Preparing for the ACT
ACT preparation requires time-management strategies due to its tight pacing. Practice mock exams with timed sections to get used to the speed. Also, spend time understanding scientific data presentation, as this skill will help in the ACT Science section.
For students planning to take both tests, it’s wise to alternate your practice sessions to build familiarity with each format.
Score Reporting and Retesting
Both the SAT and ACT allow students to take the test multiple times and submit their highest scores to colleges. Most schools accept superscoring, which means they’ll consider the highest scores in each section across multiple test dates. Retesting is common, and many students see improved scores after their second or third attempt.
For instance, one of my classmates retook the ACT twice to improve her Math and Science scores. The experience helped her build test-taking confidence, and the score increase made a difference in her college applications.
Final Thoughts: Making the Right Choice for You
Ultimately, choosing between the SAT and ACT boils down to understanding your strengths and preferences. The best way to determine your ideal test is to try practice exams and evaluate which feels more manageable. Remember, there’s no “one-size-fits-all” solution, and both exams offer a pathway to success.
Take the time to assess your skills and decide which format feels more natural. Some students even choose to take both tests to keep their options open, especially if they are applying to colleges with varying preferences.
So, consider your strengths, explore each test’s structure, and invest time in preparation. By understanding the SAT and ACT, you can confidently select the test that showcases your academic abilities and moves you closer to your college dreams.
The Science Academy Inc.
The Science Academy Inc. is a forward-thinking organization committed to inspiring and empowering the next generation of innovators, scientists, and leaders. By offering engaging STEM programs, hands-on workshops, and real-world problem-solving opportunities, the academy makes STEM education accessible and impactful for students of all ages. With a focus on fostering curiosity, creativity, and critical thinking, The Science Academy Inc. prepares young minds to excel in a rapidly evolving world. Learn more at TheScienceAcademyInc.com.
Discover the difference of The Ivy Institute—where if you can dream it, we can build it! At The Ivy Institute, we don’t just help students get accepted into top Ivy League and Ivy Plus colleges — we have the resources to develop students into the candidates top colleges and admissions officers seek, and transform your CommonApp college application and essays. Join us for a 30-minute information session on applying for college with an Ivy League expert and see how we can make your college dreams a reality. Schedule your consultation today!
