Inside the Turmoil of This Year’s College Admissions Season
“Our school’s valedictorian got denied everywhere!”
“My friend got denied from all their safeties.”
“My classmates only got on waitlists.”
These are the stories we are hearing from our students about their classmates, and they are not alone. In total, we have received well over a 100 calls from families panicking across the country reporting similar results at their schools. And rightly so… While admissions has always been extremely selective at the top schools, this year, more atypical than most, saw many top students with not a single acceptance and college to go to in the Fall.
So, what is behind these results?
The Surge in Applications
The rise in the number of applications is staggering. Take Duke University, for example, where applications have quadrupled since the early '90s. In the last five years alone, they've seen a 37% increase. This influx isn't unique to Duke; it reflects a nationwide trend that has seen the admissions process grow increasingly competitive. The upsurge is partly fueled by the test-optional policies adopted during the pandemic, encouraging more students to apply in hopes of better chances without standardized test scores.
The Supreme Court's Impact
A pivotal change in the admissions landscape came from a recent Supreme Court decision that outlawed considering race explicitly in admissions. This ruling has compelled schools to find alternative ways to maintain diversity, complicating the admissions equation further. Without explicit racial data, schools like Duke have turned to tools like the College Board's Landscape, which provides contextual information about a student’s educational and socio-economic background.
A More Selective Process
The competition has never been fiercer. At Duke, the acceptance rate has plummeted, with the university now rejecting about 95% of all applicants. This figure is a stark contrast to earlier times when acceptance and yield rates were significantly higher. The current scenario illustrates not just a more selective process but also a broader trend of increasing selectivity among the nation's most prestigious institutions.
The Strategy Game of Admissions
In response to the burgeoning application pool, colleges are employing sophisticated strategies to manage their yield rates—the percentage of accepted students who choose to enroll. These strategies include various admissions options such as early decision and early action, which are designed to lock in students earlier in the process and thereby provide colleges with a more predictable incoming class.
The Ripple Effects
The strategic maneuvers of top-tier colleges have a cascading effect on less selective institutions. These schools, in turn, adjust their own admissions policies to maintain competitiveness and attractiveness. It’s not uncommon now for less selective schools to defer more applicants in early rounds to gauge the seriousness of their intent or even deny admissions to avoid being backup options.
The Emotional Toll
The complexity of the admissions process has taken a significant emotional toll on applicants. Many high school seniors find themselves navigating a labyrinth of advice, strategies, and predictions about what admissions officers might want. This environment has fueled anxiety and confusion, complicating an already stressful decision-making process.
Looking Ahead
What does the future hold for college admissions? It seems likely that the landscape will continue to evolve, driven by legal decisions, technological advances, and changes in institutional priorities. Colleges might continue to refine their strategies to balance between selectivity and diversity, while applicants might need to adapt to an increasingly opaque and strategic game.
The world of college admissions is more turbulent and competitive than ever. For students and families navigating this maze, it's crucial to stay informed, remain flexible in their strategies, and perhaps most importantly, maintain a healthy perspective about the journey to higher education. In this high-stakes game, understanding the rules and reading the play can make all the difference.
