“The Magic Art of Saying More with Less,” by McEwan, and Writing College Admissions Essays

The essay editing bench

Cut a sentence without cutting its meaning

Ask a reader what the detail implies.

The Ivy Institute

The essay editing bench · 1/3

Find the load-bearing detail

Malky McEwan’s essay on saying more with less explores how a part can stand for a whole. In an application draft, a marked-up shift schedule can reveal a responsibility that takes several abstract sentences to explain.

Concision - Purdue OWL® - Purdue University

Before cutting a word, decide what your reader must understand

A student has a college essay that is forty words too long. They begin by replacing every phrase with a shorter synonym. After an hour, the essay meets the limit. Unfortunately, it has become hard to tell who made the most important choice. The student kept a beautiful description of the setting and removed the sentence that explained why a change was necessary. A stronger editing process would have begun with meaning. What should a reader be able to say about the student's action, reasoning or changed understanding after one ordinary read?

Malky McEwan's piece about saying more with less introduced the original column's discussion of metonymy and synecdoche. These are ways that one term or detail can stand for something larger. College applicants do not need to memorize the definitions to use the underlying idea. A marked-up schedule can suggest the work of keeping a group organized. A replacement part can recall an entire afternoon spent figuring out why a repair failed. The question is whether the person outside your life understands what the detail stands for. Brevity that increases confusion has saved the writer words at the reader's expense.

Try explaining your draft's central movement in two ordinary sentences. What did you believe, expect or try at first? What happened that made the later position different? If the essay is a description of an ongoing relationship or a practical responsibility, use a corresponding pair of questions. What regularly depended on you, and which decision changed how you approached the responsibility? You now have a test for each potential cut. A sentence that carries the connection between the two answers may deserve to stay even when it looks plain.

Before marking the draft, make a copy the student can return to. Editing invites experimentation. A version with paragraphs moved or background removed may show that an earlier passage was doing more work than you thought. Version history is also valuable when several adults provide feedback. The student can compare changes, recover original language and choose what they actually want to say. A shorter sentence is not automatically a better sentence, and an adult’s preference for polished vocabulary is not a sufficient reason to replace the writer’s phrasing.

Find one load-bearing detail

Picture a high school student who has spent a year organizing access to a shared workroom. The draft says they learned about preparation, leadership, collaboration and the importance of clear communication. Those abstractions overlap. Now imagine that a particular evening turned on a spare key and a handwritten sign-in sheet. Which was the detail that actually changed what someone could do? If the key mattered because it allowed a second person to open the space when the student worked late, the reader needs that consequence. A detail becomes valuable when it carries a piece of the story.

Try this fictional pair of sentences. “I learned how important it is to be a dependable leader” offers the reader a conclusion. “The next shift could open the room after I showed them where the approved spare key was kept” supplies an action and an effect. The second sentence might still need context about why the earlier process failed. It may also require omitting the actual location of a real key for privacy and security. The principle is to choose a detail that explains responsibility while leaving out information a public reader does not need.

An object can point beyond itself if the reader has enough information to establish the connection. A marked score may suggest practice to a musician. It could simply look like paper to someone who has never rehearsed. Show what one annotation changed. Did it tell another player where to enter, record a disagreement about phrasing or help the student notice a repeated mistake? A single specific verb can carry more information than several adjectives. Without that verb, a reference to a marked score may be short but inert.

A detail can also be misleading. A lab coat may evoke research without establishing that the student designed an experiment. A badge may identify access without proving that its wearer led an organization. If the image invites a larger claim than the student can support, supply a precise account of what they actually did. An essay about observing a method can still show careful thinking. The writer need not give themselves a more substantial role just because the object carries prestigious associations.

Cut repeated interpretation first

Read one paragraph and mark each sentence that tells the reader how to interpret the same event. A student might say they were nervous, add that they felt uncomfortable, and conclude that leaving their comfort zone was hard. Try keeping one honest observation and the decision that followed. The recovered words may allow you to say what you did when the first plan failed. Removing repetition is valuable because it frees space for new information. It need not turn the essay into a collection of short, abrupt sentences.

Look for a description that repeats a résumé fact without adding perspective. If an activity entry already identifies the club, title and weekly hours, the essay may need only enough of that background to locate the scene. Use the rest of the space for something the entry cannot convey. What choice felt uncertain? How did someone else respond? Which consequence surprised you? Repeating a familiar fact can be worthwhile when its meaning changes in the essay. Repeating it simply because it sounds impressive usually costs more than it gives.

The essay editing bench · 2/3

Make two cuts

Remove one intensifier and one sentence that interprets an image the reader already understands. Read the passage again. If the connection becomes obscure, restore the few words that carry it.

Essays | Undergraduate Admissions

Conduct three different kinds of edit

The first edit concerns structure. Does the reader receive the facts in the order needed to understand the choice? A student may explain why a decision mattered after several paragraphs describing it. Move one short piece of context earlier and see whether other explanation becomes unnecessary. Sometimes the best way to remove words is to rearrange existing information. A reader who understands the constraint at the outset will not need repeated reminders that the situation was difficult.

The second edit concerns sentences. Look for phrases that introduce a thought without changing its meaning. A student may write that “it is important for me to say” before providing the thing they wanted to say. Try reading the sentence from the substantive action. Be careful with phrases that express uncertainty or proportion. Removing “in the two sessions I observed” can turn a defensible finding into a sweeping claim. Efficiency is not a reason to strip away the qualifications that make a statement true.

The third edit concerns sound and voice. Read the draft aloud. Would the student use this wording when explaining the experience to someone they trust? A formal word may be precise and entirely natural to the writer. A plain word may better fit the rest of the paragraph. Look for changes in register introduced by different adults. If a teenager sounds like a different person every few sentences, recover the original draft and ask which version they can defend in conversation. Good editing makes a voice easier to hear.

Keep a simple decision log for consequential edits. What did you remove, what was its function and where is that function carried now? A date may be dispensable if the academic term supplies all the timing the reader needs. A single phrase identifying who made a decision may be essential if a group was involved. A local acronym may take fewer characters but need a longer explanation. Writing down the reason for a cut teaches the student how to edit the next essay without starting from zero.

What changed in actual Ivy Institute essay drafts

In an Ivy Institute review of seven paired personal statements, the median change in length was a cut of sixteen words. A net change of sixteen does not mean the writer removed only sixteen words. They could add material that makes an earlier choice clear while removing a larger amount of repetition elsewhere. The study examined matched drafts with available records. It did not establish an ideal amount to cut or prove that a certain revision caused admission. It offers a useful way to think about the difference between length and meaning.

Look at your own drafts side by side. Select one paragraph whose length barely changed. Did the student's role become more visible? Did someone else lose credit for part of a group decision? Did the revised version imply that an outcome was known sooner than it actually was? Did the editing clarify why the event mattered or replace a distinctive thought with a generic moral? These questions reveal the substance of revision. A word count alone can never tell a family whether a student has become easier to understand.

In a separate advising exchange, a student gave us two possible personal statements. Our feedback supported the draft closer to the student's voice and suggested targeted refinements. Had we begun by choosing the more dramatic subject or the shorter draft, we could have overlooked the student's preference about what to share. Use the same approach when choosing between two short revisions. Which one tells the reader something true about the applicant that the rest of the file does not already establish? The student's answer deserves weight.

A useful diagnostic is to ask what disappeared when an adult edited the draft. Perhaps a repeated sentence vanished and the paragraph improved. Perhaps the student's hesitation vanished too, leaving a neat but inaccurate picture of how confidently they acted. If uncertainty was real and central to the learning, restore it in the few words needed. Students can recognize complexity without producing a long explanation. Qualifiers such as “at first,” “in that trial” or “I had assumed” sometimes carry an entire turn in the story.

Three short editing demonstrations

Consider a fictional student writing about a community newsletter. The first draft states that they developed leadership skills by ensuring operations were efficient, smooth and effective. A revised account might say the student moved the submission deadline after two editors had to work through lunch. That sentence establishes a decision, a reason and a practical consequence. It still may need the reader to know whether the student had authority to make the change or proposed it to an editor. Choose the verb that matches what happened. The draft should never gain efficiency by gaining an invented promotion.

For a second demonstration, imagine a student writes that a science project taught them to embrace failure and never give up on their dreams. What happened in the project? A reading varied with the position of the instrument rather than the factor the student wanted to test. A sentence about how they discovered that difference gives a reader something to examine. If the next version has not yet been tested, stop at the revised plan. An unfinished investigation can make a precise ending. A broad claim about its eventual success is less honest and often less interesting.

For a third, imagine a student left a performance because another obligation changed unexpectedly. The draft spends a paragraph explaining that their life is very busy. If the crucial decision was arranging a reliable substitute, one sentence about obtaining the other performer's agreement may carry the meaning. Leave out another person's private circumstances if they are unnecessary. A reader can understand the student's judgment without knowing why a family member needed help. Good compression can improve privacy as well as pacing.

Our review of paired college essay drafts

The essay editing bench · 3/3

Test a stranger’s reading

Ask a reader what the detail implies. An inside joke or unexplained acronym may be brief and still expensive in reader effort. Choose the shorter version only when it preserves what you mean.

When the shorter version needs one more sentence

Test a detail on someone unfamiliar with your school. If they remember the object but misunderstand its significance, add context at the first point they needed it. A spare key, a rewritten timetable or a marked-up score can help a reader remember a story. It cannot substitute for identifying who needed the information or what changed. Writers sometimes save room by removing the bridge between the object and the decision. Restoring five ordinary words there can make everything around them work harder.

Another reason to restore words is chronology. A student might try a method, receive feedback, change it and discover a result over several months. If the shorter draft reports all four things in a single sentence, the reader may believe the result followed the first attempt immediately. Insert a brief timing cue where it matters. Being clear about what was known then and what became clear later helps a reader appreciate the student's learning. A simple “after the second trial” may be more effective than an additional reflective paragraph.

A third reason is authorship. If a shortened sentence claims the student built something alone when the original correctly identified a team effort, put the collaboration back. It is possible to credit a teacher, classmate or colleague while making the student's action visible. Name what the other person contributed and the decision that belonged to the writer. An essay that removes people to make the protagonist more impressive has become shorter by losing part of the truth. Accuracy earns the extra words.

Read the final version with its actual prompt above it. A shorter essay that answers a neighboring question is still the wrong submission. In an Ivy Institute review of related community responses, the student needed to assign each piece a different job and check the exact application limits. Some prompts invite context about a past experience. Others ask what the writer will do with it in the future. If the cut removed the future connection from the second type, restore it before polishing the opening again.

Edit differently for a long statement and a short response

A personal statement has room to develop sequence, tension and reflection. If you need to cut a substantial amount, start with paragraphs. Which scene repeats an idea established better elsewhere? Which background section can be replaced with a sentence near the relevant action? Trying to remove forty adjectives can leave an essay with the same pacing problem it had at the beginning. An applicant who cuts one redundant scene may have room to keep an important pause or a line that sounds distinctly like them.

A short response presents a different challenge. The reader may have asked about one academic interest or a particular community contribution. Begin with a direct answer. Then use one observation or decision as evidence and a short explanation of why it matters. If the prompt asks about a future college opportunity, confirm the name, access conditions and relevance before spending scarce words on it. A list of three impressive resources is rarely as informative as one verified opportunity the student can connect to something they have already done.

When cutting a longer statement down for another assignment, start a new document. Write the new question in full and summarize the answer the student would give in conversation. Then borrow only the details from the longer piece that serve this answer. In our advising work, a student revisiting a longer essay for a shorter format needed fresh context as well as cuts. The short version was a new task. Shrinking the old one mechanically would have preserved the earlier proportions while making the new question harder to see.

Check how the platform counts the submission. A word processor and an application field can handle hyphenation or formatting differently. The current field and its instructions determine whether the student's work fits. Read the actual preview to check for lost paragraph breaks, truncated material and an incorrect version pasted into a box. In one Ivy Institute application review, the preview revealed an additional-information passage spanning multiple pages. Reading the finished form caught a presentation issue that was easy to miss in the working draft.

Stop editing when the meaning is clear and the words belong to the student

Ask a trusted reader for three observations. What happened? Which decision belonged to the applicant? What more do you now understand about the writer? If the answers align with the student's intended meaning, resist rewriting solely to satisfy the reader's stylistic preferences. If the reader missed one important connection, fix that connection and reread the surrounding lines. Accept the description of confusion without handing another person control of the prose. The student remains the author and has to recognize the final version as their own.

Use the edit decision log below for one sentence. Put the original beside a proposed revision and identify the piece of meaning each must carry. Read both out loud, check the facts and choose the version a reader can understand with the least unnecessary work. The answer may be shorter, slightly longer or simply better arranged. The value of saying more with less lies in what the reader can see after you remove the excess: the student who chose, noticed, questioned or changed something that mattered.

One final exercise is to put the sentence back where it will actually appear. A line that looks excellent on its own can repeat the point made immediately above it. A line that seems plain in isolation may supply the reader's only clear indication of what happened next. Read the sentence before and after your change, then the whole paragraph. If the student can identify the action and the shift in understanding without explaining either twice, the passage is ready to move back into the application.

Keep an edit decision log

Detail

Original line — In an application draft, a marked-up shift schedule can reveal a responsibility that takes several abstract sentences to explain.

Cut

Possible revision — If the connection becomes obscure, restore the few words that carry it.

Restore

Meaning I must preserve — Choose the shorter version only when it preserves what you mean.

The essay editing bench

Keep an edit decision log

Use the prompts to make a note you can take to your next conversation. Your entries stay on this page.

Your working notes

Continue your work

Related reading: See what a stranger can reasonably learn and Get a stalled essay moving with one scene.

For more examples or a conversation about your plan: student case studies, advising team, contact The Ivy Institute.

As the gates to higher education swung open on August 1st, students across the nation found themselves diving headfirst into their college applications. This annual rite of passage, though anticipated, is no small feat. Among the myriad challenges faced during this period, a recurring question echoes in the corridors of uncertainty: "How can I encapsulate my entire life within the confines of a mere 650 words?"

Indeed, the Common App and supplemental essays pose a daunting task. Weaving one's life story, passions, and aspirations into a canvas as compact as a tweet can feel like threading a needle in a gusty wind. Yet, for those who embrace and wield the art of creative writing, this seemingly Herculean feat becomes an opportunity for brilliance.

Recently, we stumbled upon a timely and thought-provoking article penned by Malky McEwan, titled "The Magic Art of Saying More with Less." Strikingly, McEwan's insights echoed many of the sentiments we hold dear at The Ivy Institute. Our mantras such as "let your actions be your voice," the importance of "showing" over "telling" when addressing admissions officers, and the notion that colleges possess the keen ability to "read between the lines" all find resonance in McEwan's words.

McEwan's article sheds light on the profound truth that lies within these statements. Amidst the dynamic landscape of college applications, the canvas isn't merely limited to what a student chooses to express through words. Instead, it extends beyond—to the realm of what remains unspoken. It is within this interplay between the articulated and the unarticulated that a myriad of stories and possibilities unfurl.

Just as a skilled artist uses the spaces between brushstrokes to craft a more captivating image, so too can a student harness the power of omission, letting the unwritten sentences resonate with their own narrative. This is a world where the unwritten paragraphs often carry as much weight as those meticulously penned. This perspective transcends the conventional boundaries of storytelling, inviting students to wield the subtle art of suggestion and the eloquence of the unsaid.

McEwan's insights beautifully converge with our philosophy at The Ivy Institute, magnifying the intricate dance between words and the unspoken, narrative and implication. It underscores the notion that a well-crafted college application isn't merely a collection of words, but a tapestry interwoven with the subtlety of the untold.

Within the article, McEwan's insights resonated deeply with the journey of crafting effective and triumphant college application essays. Beyond captivating storytelling, McEwan delves into a realm where each word, meticulously chosen, becomes an instrument of nuance. McEwan guides us through the terrain of metonymy and synecdoche. Just as Leone's portrayal of a train station's details fuels intrigue, so too can the judicious use of these literary devices enhance the narrative economy of application essays.


McEwan states: Metonymy, the art of substituting a word or phrase with something related, mirrors how "the oval office" signifies not just a room but an entire administration. Metonymy bridges concepts and beckons readers to read between the lines.

“Metonymy is a figure of speech where we use a word to refer to something related to that thing, such as wheels to refer to a car. Wheels represent the entire car."

"Using metonymy we can say the pen is mightier than the sword where the pen stands for the written word and the sword stands for military aggression."


Synecdoche, is Metonymy’s sibling, imbues phrases like "all hands on deck" with vivid imagery and depth. In creative hands, these devices paint portraits that resonate, taking readers beyond the written word.


McEwan’s continues to say: “Synecdoche takes metonymy a step further. It is a figure of speech that involves using a part of something to represent the whole, or occasionally vice versa."

"A classic example of synecdoche is the use of the term hands to mean workers, as in all hands on deck."

"Synecdoche evokes mental imagery in the reader. You can’t read gray hairs should be respected without imagining the group of older people they are attached to."

"Synecdoche can be a part of something that represents the whole, vice versa is also true... Downing Street called a press conference. Streets, even one that houses the Prime Minister, don’t call a conference — that’s the job of the press secretary."


These techniques echo through casual dialogue, where the briefest allusion speaks volumes. As Caesar's "lend me your ears" commands attention, so too does a whispered nickname create vivid impressions, honing in on the essence of a person. With McEwan's guidance, students are poised to harness metonymy and synecdoche as tools for eloquence.

In the competitive arena of college applications, the pressure to excel can stifle creativity. Yet, as prospective scholars undertake the task of essay composition, they find a guiding light in the techniques employed by cinematic auteurs and literary wordsmiths. Just as Leone crafts tension in silence, so too can the aspiring student balance the unsaid with the written word.

The road to higher education is paved with stories waiting to be told, passions longing to be shared, and dreams yearning to be realized. And while the word count may appear limiting, it is in these confines that true artistry flourishes. As the curtain rises on this year's application season, may the wisdom of McEwan and the cinematic masters empower students to craft essays that not only captivate but also transcend the constraints, revealing the boundless potential within each carefully chosen word.

Previous
Previous

Are you facing “writers block” while writing your college admissions essays? Here’s a TikTok trend that can help!

Next
Next

Admissions Review: “Is it possible for me to be accepted in the Ivy league under these conditions?” (Reddit Post)